Professor Henry Srebrnik

Professor Henry Srebrnik

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

El-Sayed Victory in Michigan is a Dangerous Moment for American Jews

By Henry Srebrnik, Jewish Post, Winnipeg

The election on Nov. 3 to the United States Senate of a man whose links with Palestinian and antizionist radicals is a watershed in American politics. For the first time, with the victory of Dr. Abdul El-Sayed on the Democratic ticket in Michigan, the wall has been breached against voting for an openly antisemitic politician running for a major party. He beat Republican Mike Rogers 52 to 46 per cent.

This has followed the equally disturbing win by Zohran Mamdani as mayor of New York last year, even though that city has the largest population of Jews of any municipality outside Israel. Both results signal a dangerous turn in national politics, especially on the left.

El-Sayed has left many “tells” regarding his extremist views. According to audio from a private campaign strategy call made on March 1, obtained by the Washington Free Beacon and published on March 30, El-Sayed told staffers he wanted to avoid making a public statement about the assassination of Ayatollah Ali Khamenei the previous day by Israel during the Iran war because “there are a lot of people in Dearborn,” whose Muslim population is estimated to make up about 41 per cent of the city’s people, “who are sad” about his death.  

The paper also, on Oct. 6, reported that Mohammad Ali Elahi, the imam of the Islamic House of Wisdom in Dearborn Heights, hosted El-Sayed at his mosque on June 24, organized an anti-Israel roundtable for El-Sayed on July 21, and attended a Dearborn fundraiser in August that raised $350,000 for his Senate bid.

Elahi, who claimed after 9/11 that Mossad and Israel perpetrated the terrorist attacks, served as head of the Iranian Navy’s political-ideological office, a post to which he was appointed by Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini, the late Iranian supreme leader. He helped create a research unit for Khomeini's Martyrs Foundation, which the U.S. government sanctioned in 2007 over its support for Hezbollah and other terrorist groups.  Elahi, who immigrated to Dearborn in 1992, has also maintained ties to high-level Iranian political and religious leaders.

His father sits on the board of an Islamic charity that was previously accused of funneling cash to late Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein’s regime. Imam Dr. Mohammed El-Sayed is currently a board member of Life for Relief and Development, a charity he’s worked with since at least 2020, according to tax forms. Eman Abdelhadi, El-Sayed’s half-sister, is a University of Chicago associate professor in the Department of Comparative Human Development and prominent anti-Israel activist who frequently and publicly utilizes antisemitic rhetoric that she shares with her 45,000 followers on social media.

Abe Greenwald, the executive editor of Commentary magazine, published by the American Jewish Committee, on Oct. 20, in “The Disavowal Game,” rhetorically posed the following to El-Sayed:

“Your father-in-law, Tayeb Jukaku, the largest individual donor to your campaign, is a member of the Islamic Society of North America and a founder and board director at the Council on American-Islamic Relations. Both groups are unindicted co-conspirators in the USA v. Holy Land Foundation for Relief and Development case, in which Holy Land Foundation leaders were convicted of terrorism-related charges. Federal prosecutors also linked both groups to the Muslim Brotherhood.

“Your half-sister, Eman Abdelhadi, delivered an October 7 ‘blessing’ on Instagram, one year after the Hamas massacre in Israel. ‘I want to say, Allahu Akbar,’ she began. ‘That phrase means God is greater, and it’s an important phrase in the Muslim tradition. It’s one that I've been thinking about a lot over the last year, because it's a phrase that reminds us that no matter how great the brutality, the oppression, the intensity of what we're going through, the horizon of justice is just around the corner.’ There was not a word about October 7 itself or the slaughter of Jews. But she urged viewers to ‘grieve all the siblings that we’ve lost over the past year.’ 

“According to social media posts from this same half-sister, your mother, Fatten Fathy Elkomy, had been involved in the Muslim Brotherhood, and many other family members continue to be active in the organization. Additionally, your mother worked for the Islamic American Relief Agency, which was designated by the U.S. Treasury Department in 2004 for financially supporting Osama bin Laden and various terrorist organizations.

“Your sister-in-law, Mariam Jukaku, was reportedly placed on a federal terrorism watchlist during the Obama administration. She joined a lawsuit to get her name taken off the list and, despite your claims, did not win. 

“Of course, it’s not fair to pass judgment on someone based solely on the sins of his family. Which is why I’ll now turn to you. I’d imagine that it would be traumatic for a non-extremist Muslim to find himself in a family of committed Islamists and terrorist enablers. I’d think you’d make a point of distancing yourself from their extremism. And yet, you speak and act as if you’re in their camp. 

“In 2012, you signed a letter of support for Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi, a Muslim Brotherhood leader, urging him to purge the country’s dissenting media and police. You empathized with the terrorist who tried to blow up the Temple Israel Synagogue and day school in March. ‘Hurt people,’ you explained, ‘hurt people.’ You continually refuse to renounce the theocratic Iranian regime. Nor have you said whether Iran or Israel poses a greater threat to the United States. You’ve defended the existence of shariah law in the U.S. You’ve boasted, to select audiences, that you’re actually an Egyptian immigrant. Why? Your friend Hasan Piker is a supporter of every Brotherhood terrorist offshoot I can think of. And you’ve not denounced him either.”

The charity, the Islamic American Relief Agency, founded in 1985, raised at least $20 million and funded social services for children in Africa and Asia, according to federal records. It closed in 2024 after the terrorism designation. Its executive director, Mubarak Hamed, was sentenced in 2012 to nearly five years in prison.

Greenwald’s reference to Temple Israel, located in heavily-Jewish West Bloomfield, a suburb of Detroit, concerned the terrorist attack on March 12 by Hezbollah supporter Ayman Ghazali, who drove a truck laden with explosives and accelerants into the reinforced doors of Michigan’s largest synagogue, and opened fire on the temple’s security personnel. Ghazali was killed before he could detonate his vehicular IED inside the building in which 140 Jewish preschoolers were in attendance at the time of the attack.

“We can and must condemn the attack on Temple Israel, and we can and must condemn the violence 6,000 miles away,” El-Sayed responded, explaining that just days earlier, the gunman had lost members of his extended family in an Israeli air strike in Lebanon. But he failed to mention that one of those relatives was a Hezbollah commander who managed weapons operations in southern Lebanon.

El-Sayed refused to condemn Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps, saying, “It is the responsibility of the people of Iran to decide what their leadership should look like.” In his debate against Rogers, he declined to say whether Israel or Iran posed a greater threat to America.

Federal Election Commission records show that El-Sayed’s campaign collected over $115,000 from officials and leaders affiliated with the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR). Among the identified donors is CAIR National Executive Director Nihad Awad, who drew widespread condemnation after publicly stating he was “happy” to see Hamas break out of Gaza on October 7, 2023 and arguing Israel “does not have the right to self-defence” as an occupying power.

The Democratic Senate hopeful told the SenseSustainability podcast in a 2011 interview that he draws inspiration from Tariq Ramadan, the grandson of the Muslim Brotherhood founder, the Egyptian imam and educator Hassan Al-Banna. Ramadan is the son of Said Ramadan, who was married to Al-Banna’s daughter and emerged as a top Brotherhood leader in the wake of al-Banna’s death.

El-Sayed also appears to have a personal relationship with Mohamed Soltan, the son of a senior Muslim Brotherhood official. In a since-deleted Substack post, he called Soltan, who was jailed in Egypt for his role in a series of 2013 protests aimed at reinstating Egypt’s Muslim Brotherhood-affiliated president, Mohamed Morsi, his “friend,” the Washington Free Beacon reported Oct. 13.

Over the weekend of Oct. 24-25, an independent left-wing political action committee entered the Michigan Senate race on behalf of El-Sayed. Rebellion PAC released a web ad that featured a couple at the grocery store discussing how they could not afford bananas and eggs because “we have to set that money aside for killing Palestinians.” El-Sayed refused to criticize it. So important is his antisemitic worldview that he was even willing to potentially lose a winnable seat rather than simply admit that, no, the “Zionist lobby” isn’t responsible for the rise in the cost of bananas, or skyrocketing healthcare premiums. Not every domestic problem has a single, sinister foreign architect.  It led to a break with centrist members of the Democratic Party, including Congresswoman Haley Stevens, the woman he defeated in the Aug. 4 primary.

He attacked her for being a puppet of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC).  In August El-Sayed had taunted AIPAC at a virtual town hall. “I’m happy to burn your money for you,” he remarked. “And then we can get on to the business of governing and asking whether or not our foreign policy ought to be dictated to us by the interests of a foreign government.” Just two days before the election, she announced she was endorsing Rogers, after she was uninvited to a joint event with El-Sayed.

In the primary, Stevens had defeated El-Sayed in Wayne County, which includes Detroit, and neighbouring Oakland County, drawing support from Black and Jewish voters who are important parts of the Democratic coalition.

The Democratic party leaders, for their part, have shamefully struck a bargain with the left and put up with anything to win elections. Senator Chuck Schumer of New York, who is Jewish, called her move a “despicable betrayal.”

One reason El-Sayed didn’t confront the ad might be because Rebellion PAC is run by an ally of the campaign, Cenk Uygur, a podcaster obsessed with the perfidy of Israel and its supporters in America. El-Sayed appeared with Uygur in September at a conference sponsored by the Islamic Society of North America. Uygur’s nephew is the anti-American streamer Hasan Piker, who campaigned with El-Sayed in the final weeks of his primary campaign. Piker has argued that the authors of the October 7 massacre, Hamas, are morally superior to Israel, and stated that his favourite flag was that of Hezbollah, the Lebanese terrorist group. He has also suggested that America “deserved” the attacks on 9/11 in 2001. Tucker Carlson, the influential far-right podcaster, also took to defending El-Sayed. They find common ground in their shared criticism of interventionist foreign policy and the Israeli government.

In office, El-Sayed will obsess over the Jewish state. He will prioritize ending the U.S. relationship with Israel -- indeed, he’s already indicated he wants a seat on the Foreign Relations Committee -- and anytime someone has a positive thing to say about it, he will “remind” people of its “genocide” in Gaza.

Michigan has nearly twice as many Muslims as Jews. If current trends continue, similar ratios will become increasingly common throughout the country. How will that change America, and the place of Jews in it? As in most of the world, demography is destiny.

 

Michigan Elects First Muslim to U.S. Senate

 By Henry Srebrnik, Saint John Telegraph-Journal

In the American mid-term elections to Congress held Nov. 3, the voters in Michigan elected Democratic Party candidate Abdul El-Sayed to the U.S. Senate. He beat his Republican opponent, former Representative Mike Rogers by 52 to 46 per cent.

Born to Egyptian immigrants and raised in the Detroit area, the 41-year-old son of an engineering professor who has served as a Sunni Muslim imam, El-Sayed is a University of Michigan graduate and a former athlete. After graduation, he became a Rhodes Scholar, obtaining a doctorate from Oxford University, then went on to attend Columbia University medical school, earning his medical degree. An epidemiologist, he served as director of Wayne County’s Department of Health, Human, and Veterans Services before running for office.

El-Sayed has been a fixture in Michigan politics since 2018, when he ran to become the state’s next governor -- and the first Muslim governor in the nation. Although he lost to Governor Whitmer by more than 20 per cent, he did better than expected.

On his path toward becoming the Democratic nominee, El-Sayed, whose many positions align with those of the left-wing Democratic Socialists of America, defeated the centrist Democratic Congresswoman Haley Stevens in the Aug. 4 Democratic primary. He attacked Stevens for being a puppet of the American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC). Citing Jewish worries, she later endorsed Rogers.

In August El-Sayed taunted AIPAC at a virtual town hall. “I’m happy to burn your money for you,” he remarked. “And then we can get on to the business of governing and asking whether or not our foreign policy ought to be dictated to us by the interests of a foreign government.”

As James J. Zogby, the president of the Arab American Institute, a Washington, D.C.-based organization which serves as the political and policy research arm of the Arab American community, observed on Aug. 10, “I am hard pressed to find an election that was more consequential and broke ground in more areas than this Michigan primary contest.”

A day later, El-Sayed called Israel “bloodthirsty” and said his critiques went beyond the Netanyahu government, arguing that the longtime U.S. ally should not exist as an explicitly Jewish state and calling for an end to its American military support.

Rogers, El-Sayed’s Republican opponent, attempted to shave off slices of voters from various Democratic-leaning constituencies, especially Jews. The Rogers campaign ran an ad featuring a young Persian American man arguing that El-Sayed is too closely linked to radical Islam and al-Qaeda. In a television ad, Rogers also claimed that the Democrat “has ties to the Muslim Brotherhood” and “publicly supported these terrorists,” as images of El-Sayed superimposed over footage of Hamas militants in Gaza appear on the screen behind him. The ad closed with Rogers warning that “Abdul El-Sayed’s radical ideology is a threat to our national security.”

President Donald Trump also ramped up rhetoric against El-Sayed at a rally Oct. 25 in Port Huron. “I’m here to keep a jihadist Muslim Brotherhood member from becoming a United States senator,” he said.

None of this hampered El-Sayed. Indeed, he doubled down on his view that Israel is not a U.S. ally. In an interview with MS Now on Oct. 15, he had stated that “the government of Israel has done nothing but use us” and “has done terrible things with our money.” The Israeli military “has done heinous things, full war crimes, genocide. So I think we got to just get serious about whether or not we as a country should be subsidizing that government.”

Former President Barack Obama came to Detroit Oct. 24 to tell Michiganders to vote for El-Sayed. Instead of addressing Jewish Michiganders’ legitimate concerns about El-Sayed, Obama sidestepped all that, offering up anodyne comments about their shared values. (This apparently affronted some Democrats.) In turn, El-Sayed likened Obama to a father figure.

“I want to keep our tax dollars here at home instead of sending them abroad to fight wars we have no business fighting,” El-Sayed said, referring to the war with Iran. Michigan Democratic Party chair Curtis Hertel warned the attendees that Republicans were trying to launch a “whisper” campaign that Abdul El-Sayed is not American. “There is nothing more American than Abdul El-Sayed.”

Representative Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York, who also headlined rallies in Michigan for El-Sayed, called his election crucial to the “progressive” movement. “AOC,” as her supporters call her, followed that up with donation of one million dollars from her political account to support him. She is already being considered a possible presidential candidate in 2028. Senator Bernie Sanders of Vermont also made a one-million-dollar contribution to El-Sayed’s campaign.

Not surprisingly. El-Sayed was endorsed by Michigan Representative Rashida Tlaib, one of the few sitting Arab Americans in Congress, and by Somali-born Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar. New York mayor Zohran Mamdani, who won his election last year, appeared at a tightly controlled fundraiser for the Democratic nominee in New York.

El-Sayed’s victory is the clearest sign yet that his party’s old establishment is under siege. His entry into national politics serves as a litmus test for the strength of the left-wing of the Democratic Party heading into the next presidential contest. Early jockeying for the 2028 nomination will emerge almost immediately after these midterms.

 

 

Thursday, November 05, 2026

Will Mass Immigration Lead to Collapse of Western Political Inclinations?

 By Henry Srebrnik, Saint John Telegraph-Journal

The horrors of Nazi race theory led to the murder of millions of innocent people. As a postwar reaction, it became taboo to assert that ethnicities or religious groups differ in their readiness to adapt to Western institutions. To acknowledge the reality of profound cultural differences was now beyond the pale. Every link between peoplehood and political inclinations was verboten.

Instead, this was replaced by the belief that nations must henceforth be “ideas” rather than historical inheritances -- which meant anyone arriving would immediately realize that the benefits of liberal democracy outweighed whatever cultural and religious norms they brought with them and join the polity. A win-win situation.

That postwar rejection of “ethnopolitical” thinking produced a liberalism that contended that belonging is for “everyone,” and treated every border as a nuisance, if not a prejudice. Hence, we have today’s European Union. Ideally, the Brussels bureaucrats would like to erase even indigenous national differences in some far-off future, the way Russian Communists assumed that the various ethnic groups in the USSR would blend into a new Soviet nationality under Communism.

In the last half-century in Europe, this kind of thinking allowed for massive postwar immigration and a resulting dependence on population growth. As native birth rates declined below replacement levels, these countries became dependent on immigration to sustain their economies and social systems.

But it didn’t work out the way they expected, and so you have a liberal capitalist order now in crisis. Multiculturalism and globalization have profoundly altered communities. As such, public trust has measurably declined. Shared identity, traditions, and a common sense of belonging have all eroded. Illegal migrants are dispersed nationwide, and – of course! -- disproportionately housed in poorer neighbourhoods, away from those who rule.

In European debates today, migration is not simply presented as a problem to be managed. Rather, its opponents now hold it responsible for a gamut of problems, from poor social services to wage stagnation to crime. The rioting and disorder in France are a harbinger of what may be coming everywhere. What they are now living through is the unravelling of the postwar liberal order. Eventually, this divergence between what most of the population wants and what leaders prefer will bring down governments across the Continent, as surely as “socialism” collapsed in eastern Europe and Russia last century.

Europe’s political and social problems surrounding immigration will become even more intractable. Germany is an obvious example. Within a decade, even in its most urban and populated areas, it went from a stable nation with high levels of social trust and generous social safety nets, to something rather different. Everyone there knows the cause, everyone sees the “elephant in the room” -- it’s immigration, lawful and otherwise.

There is a frustration with immigrants who don’t seek to integrate into the fabric of the culture and its identity, or at least seek to understand and respect it, but who desire to change the identity of the countries in which they move or to create isolationist enclaves within them. The broader illiberal treatment of women by some non-Western immigrants to Europe, for example, is a ticking time bomb, and tensions are likely to continue rising, especially as Western populations continue to reject mass immigration at every electoral opportunity. Western leaders, of course, are more eager to prove their cosmopolitan bona fides and dedication to postwar liberal principles. 

The rise of right wing parties has been driven in most European countries by public perception showing recent immigrants have disproportionately been involved in crime and have resisted many liberal norms for cultural and or religious reasons, and in at least a few of these countries, well grounded data supports the perception, so much so that some countries, like Denmark and Sweden, have enacted strict controls on immigration and asylum for more than just political reasons.

France will elect a new president on April 18, and it looks as if the Rassemblement National’s Marine Le Pen might finally win in her fourth attempt. In Spain, the leftist prime minister Pedro Sanchez has just called snap elections for November 29 and is in trouble over the Ceueta incursion by Moroccans last summer. German Chancellor Friedrich Merz lurches from crisis to crisis as the far-right Alternative fur Deutschland gains strength in regional elections. In Italy, Giorgia Meloni is already too conservative for many tastes, but her supporters may defect to Roberto Vannacci’s authentically fascist Futuro Nazionale. A decrepit Labour Party in Britain faces Nigel Farage’s Reform UK party on the right.

These right-wing parties draw moral force from claiming to represent people who consider the parties of the left to have forgotten them. Their supporters are united by a sense of meaninglessness that was once filled by other structures and parties which no longer give them a framework for identity.

Anti-immigration policies are essentially about providing an identity, whether rooted in whiteness, language, Christianity or something else. Mainstream parties need to come up with competitive platforms. The right thrives on the questions everyone else refuses to answer.

The immigration issue is fundamentally a fight between universalism and particularism. The state has been attempting to reshape society around a secular, universalist moral ideology. We don’t yet know which side will prevail.