Professor Henry Srebrnik

Professor Henry Srebrnik

Monday, September 10, 2018

Should Donald Trump be Impeached?

By Henry Srebrnik, [Summerside, PEI] Journal Pioneer

The Wall Street Journal, in an editorial of Aug. 24, “The Forbidden ‘I Word,’” asserted that Democrats want to hide their only agenda for 2019: the impeachment of President Donald Trump.

“Whatever else you do, please don’t mention the ‘I word’ between now and November. That’s the public message from Democratic leaders and most of their media friends this week after Michael Cohen’s guilty plea and his criminal allegations against President Trump. Between now and Election Day, ‘impeachment’ is the forbidden word.”

Cohen, the president’s former lawyer, revealed in court that Trump asked him to pay hush money to women who alleged they had affairs with Trump. These were criminal violations of abstruse and complicated campaign-finance laws. He was also charged with tax evasion and bank fraud.

Almost simultaneously, Paul Manafort, a former Trump campaign chair, was found guilty of tax and bank fraud.

Should Trump be impeached and removed from office? I know I speak for very few Canadians, and probably not more than half of all Americans, when I say no.

We know Trump is a liar and a loutish man. I, an American citizen, didn’t vote for him in 2016. But so were Bill Clinton and Lyndon Johnson. Nevertheless, he did win the election and nothing he has done so far merits removal from office.

Actually, from the very minute Trump was elected, the political establishment (aka “deep state”), through its media agencies, political police, and judiciary, set out to remove him. 

It’s a shame the term deep state conjures up images of sinister conspiracy. Properly used, it simply refers to those who, though often unelected officials, wield tremendous influence and political power. 

The editors of the New York Times and Washington Post, for example, are two examples; billionaire philanthropist George Soros, a one-man alternate “State Department,” is another.

President Dwight Eisenhower on leaving office in 1959 warned about the “military-industrial complex” – just another name for it.

Whispers about impeachment, the most familiar constitutional procedure for removing a president, began to circulate even before Trump had taken the oath of office.

Remember the marches and calls for “resistance?” They began the very day of his inauguration. And he’s been under siege ever since.

His enemies have even turned a porn actress into a savior of the republic! You think I jest? A New York Times opinion article of Aug. 26 by Jill Filipovic was titled “Stormy Daniels, Feminist Hero.”

The Manafort and Cohen trials, as well as the ongoing Robert Mueller investigation of alleged collusion between Trump and Russian President Vladimir Putin to win the election – still completely unproven and considered by many a “witch hunt” -- are politically motivated.

No one would have ever gone after those two men had Trump not become president, because such white-collar crimes rarely lead to indictments. 

“I really don’t think it’s about justice,” maintains the left-wing journalist Glen Greenwald, in an interview in the Sept. 3 New Yorker. “I think the people who are doing this are genuinely offended by the entire Trump circle,” and “they’re just using the law as a political weapon against Trump.” This is more persecution than prosecution.

The current hysteria over Russia’s “meddling,” were it not a weapon against Trump, would hardly have made the news. Added Greenwald, “anyone who criticizes the Democratic Party or its leaders is instantly accused of being a Kremlin agent.” 

What are the “high crimes and misdemeanors” they’ll get Trump for? Technicalities, mainly, which in other circumstances have largely gone unnoticed. 

Up until now neither the establishment nor the mainstream media has made a case for anything other than their dislike for an anti-establishment outsider.

Impeachment should require direct and undeniable evidence of specific criminal acts or abuses of power tied directly to Trump himself — not just to people around him.

Trump’s real “crime” was winning the election against the candidate of the political class that rules America. He is, in their eyes, an illegitimate president. This couldn’t be allowed to stand.

This was evident in the spectacle that followed Senator John McCain’s death, when they closed ranks to vilify Trump.

What the Democratic Party doesn’t realize is that they are making it the “new normal” to investigate, interrogate all known associates and acquaintances and relatives of an incoming president, to destroy that person.

Removing a president should be done through the ballot box, by the American public -- or American democracy will never be the same again.

No comments: